In Cultural Identity and Diaspora, Stuart Hall discusses two ways of defining cultural identity. He first explains it as a collective, shared “one true self”. This definition is based on the shared historical experiences and cultural traditions that make for a very stable sense of cultural identity. On the other hand, he presents a second definition that is more fluid. He posits that there are significant differences that influence what we become. This definition acknowledges the elements that cause shifts in identity. It also helps contextualize how colonialism impacts cultural identity and a sense of self. I personally agree more with his second definition because cultural identity is very much something that can be developed over time and with experience. This relates to cultural organizations on campus. I am part of the Filipinx-American community, and many of us had to develop our cultural identity through these spaces. Overall, Hall’s reading provides thought-provoking insight on cultural identity.
Question: How can cultural identity differ when living in the homeland versus living in the West/host country?
This reading reminded me of double consciousness where one feels torn between different identities which makes it hard to feel a unified sense of cultural identity.
Works Cited:
http://www.theinclusionsolution.me/point-view-double-consciousness-women/
Hall, Stuart. (1990). 'Cultural identity and diaspora' in Jonathan Rutherford (ed.) Identity: community, culture, difference, London: Lawrence & Wishart, pp. 222-37
No comments:
Post a Comment