Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Week 7: Identity

        Identity plays a huge role in everyone. It is how you are determined of who you are and where you come from. In Valverde's article, she talks about the artist Huynh Chau and how Chau struggled to learn of her own identity through the Vietnamese American community.  As many controversies came upon Chau and her artworks, she did not give up for what her art pieces were about and her beliefs. Many Vietnamese in America today still struggle to find their identity in being an American and also Vietnamese. I understand that it is a difficult task for these Vietnamese Americans because it is also difficult for my own community, the Hmong. The Hmong people have a similar story to the Vietnamese where many have immigrated to America after the Vietnam war of 1975 and are living in a diaspora also. Many Hmong people now in America still tries to preserve and keep their Hmong identities alive in many ways. Just like how the Vietnamese anti-communists' group do by protesting to keep their collective memories of their identity alive,  one of the ways the Hmong help kept their identity alive is by holding huge new year celebrations each year.
http://www.examiner.com/images/blog/EXID3095/images/hmong.jpg
During the new year, the Hmong wear beautiful traditional clothing and perform traditional singing and games. A question to ask yourself is what does it truly mean to you to help preserve your own cultural identity and how can you do so? As Chau did, she kept her identity alive through her artworks.

   Identity, culture, and gender is a huge part of our identities and cultures. Purnima Mankekar analyzed the film, Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge (The lover wins the bride) and looked closely at the Indian overseas issues and "non resident Indians" from the west. How Indian culture portrays gender roles and a culture identity through marriage.

                                                Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge

      In Theorizing Diaspora, Arjun Appadurai "argues against the notion that relationships in the new global cultural economy can be reduced to a simple center-periphery model" (25).
Appadurai describes the five different types of scapes and how they are important to us. For example, technoscapes, where technology is everywhere and that is how everything is seen worldwide through media, internet, etc. Appadurai says these are important because it is how "communities are forged transnationally..." (25).
   It makes sense to me and I do agree with Appadurai that these five scapes exists in our daily lives. It is how everyone communicate, travel, and learn today. It is important that we understand these concepts and know how it functions because it will be able to help us understand the process of globalization more.





Study Questions:
1) What are the "three spheres of influence" and their purposes? Explain how each one is able to effect Vietnamese overseas and also Vietnamese in America.

2) Explain what the term diaspora is according to Stefan Helmreich. How does the term diaspora come about in the film Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge according to Makekar? What is important about the film?

3) What are the "five different types of imagined world landscapes?" Explain what is Appadurai's opinion on them and what is his argument on them.

4) What is "cultural insiderism?" Explain the idea and purpose of the term. Give an example.

5) According to Stuart Hall and other theorists of the Birmingham school, what does being apart of a subculture mean? Give examples from the reading and explain.

By: Jou Xiong

3 comments:

  1. I enjoyed watching Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge. This is my first Bollywood film that I have watched and it was very entertaining. It was just interesting to me to see what their culture is like and also how important it is. This week was about identity and what I got out of the movie was that the father of Simran was more connected with his culture and wanted to continue on the traditional arranged marriage. As for Simran and Raj their identity of being Indian American drift them away from being traditional and keeping their cultural values. However, it was interesting to see how two completely different identities of father and daughter come together. It was really difficult for Simran’s father to accept her with being with Raj because he wanted to stick with the traditional arranged marriage, which is meaningful and respected among the Indians. However, in the end it was great to see him come to an understanding of his daughter and her identity and let her go with Raj.
    ~Karina Lathrop

    ReplyDelete
  2. In this weekly’s blog I found out that identity plays a huge role in everyone because it is how you are determined of who you are and where you come from. I have also learned about the dying breed of Hmong people. Hmong are striving to keep their identity and make their communities grow. The Hmong and Vietnamese are both Southeast Asian, so somewhat slightly easily comparable.
    In Theorizing Diaspora, Appadurai describes the five ethnoscapes that help the world go around. It is how everyone communicates, travels, and learn today. These terms from globalization, which is a certain process that involves multiple processes that formulate into globalization.
    I believe globalization is the only way America keeps growing with the help of other countries. It also benefits the other countries by creating a mutual partnership so that businesses could be booming and helping each country grow together.

    ~ Michael Nguyen

    ReplyDelete
  3. I found Valverde’s article about the Vietnamese artist Huynh Chao very insightful. Prior to this article, I had not known that most Vietnamese people in Vietnam did not know about the plight of the Vietnamese boat people. I felt upset knowing that the Vietnamese government attempted to cover up this portion of its history. It really angered me that they even had the audacity to make it look like it was the Vietnamese boat people’s fault for fleeing.
    At the same time, I felt really bad for Huynh Chao because my community in San Jose, CA came after her. As a second generation Vietnamese-American born in the United States, I will never understand the type of hate, struggle, and pain that the Vietnamese boat people had to go through; once for losing their country, and another for uprooting their lives.

    I had to say however, that Huynh Chao’s ability to paint a mural after learning about the atrocities the Vietnamese boat people faced gave me renewed hope that the narrative can be changed. Vietnam should be apologetic towards the diaspora since it relies so heavily on it for remittances. That’s my personal belief.

    -Ricky Lai

    ReplyDelete